GLASGOW HERALD:
Music by Vladimir Rebikov is really worth listening to.
Here is a revelation. Some insiders have been dubbing Vladimir Rebikov “the Father of Russian Music”. To the world at large, however, he is an unknown. Not even his name, far less any of his music, is going to be familiar. Born in Siberia in 1866, Rebikov died in 1920. He has been said to pre-date in his experimentalism absolutely everything from Stravinsky's Rite of Spring to Messiaen's Quartet for the End of Time. That's extravagant but the music which is on this CD, almost all of it recorded for the first time, should really have music lovers sitting up. It is abundantly original, not least in its tendency to be spiky, angular and aphoristic: it says what it has to say then stops. It will remind you of Prokofiev or Bartok; then you will hear something like Ravel or Satie or Chopin without the perfume. You will hear music which is written with whole-tone scales, orientalisms and pounding dissonances. Pianist Anthony Goldstone's championship is authoritative and gripping.
Michael Tumelty

FANFARE:
Divine Art has truly struck gold with this release of piano music by the little-known Vladimir Rebikov (1866–1920). A pupil of Nikolai Klenovsky, himself one of Tchaikovsky's pupils, Rebikov wrote music that is seldom if ever Tchaikovskian. As pianist Anthony Goldstone put it in his liner notes, “He wrote in a bewildering array of styles. Some of the composers, most of whom flowered later, whose music is brought to mind by that of Rebikov are: Satie, Poulenc, Milhaud, Bartók, Stravinsky, Copland, Chávez, Ives, Cowell, Debussy, Scriabin, Prokofiev, Messiaen, Mompou, Villa-Lobos, and Vaughan Williams. Lack of key signatures, time signatures, bar lines, ‘hanging,' unresolved endings and fades, harmonies based on fourths, sevenths and ninths—these were some of his trademarks.”

If the above quote doesn't intrigue you, your musical curiosity is dead and should be buried in the back yard next to your late, lamented pet dog or cat. If you don't believe it, then simply buy this disc and hear for yourself. Rebikov was a genius of monumental proportions—one might say the Russian Alkan—who wrote in exactly the opposite dimensions. Whereas Alkan's music is extremely long (he is sometimes described as the Mahler of the piano), Rebikov wrote in short, terse statements. Of the 42(!) pieces on this CD, none run longer than two and a half minutes with the lone exception of his “musical-psychological tableau,” Esclavage et liberté. Most of them—I kid you not—run a minute and 40 seconds or less (34 of them, to be exact). Rebikov was not a composer who wasted your time, but ironically I think it is because his musical statements are so terse that he was rarely if ever programmed in recitals. Indeed, I'd say there is another connection to Alkan, that this disc by Goldstone is as much a revelation of Rebikov's genius—and as spectacularly played—as the late Raymond Lewenthal's 1963 RCA Victor LP was revelatory of Alkan.

The proof is all there in the listening. Rebikov's strange alchemy of Alkan, Debussy, Scriabin, Satie, Stravinsky, Prokofiev, et al., leaps out at the listener with stunning audacity. Describing these short, compact, almost enigmatic works is virtually impossible. Even Goldstone has trouble doing so in his liner notes, and he's the performer! And since he appears to be an excellent note writer as well, I shall let he who has actually seen these scores, and doesn't just analyze by ear, make a few comments:

Les Démons s'amusent: “At 19 seconds into The Devils Amuse Themselves … the central melody strikingly anticipates the sinister ostinato that begins at figure 65 of Stravinsky's The Rite of Spring.”

Esclavage et liberté: “The opening section, with its idée fixe of a descending chromatic scale—a moan or cry of anguish (later becoming a scream)—ideally requires three hands. Passages of plaintive recitative express self-doubt or inner turmoil, and sudden impulses take the music off in new directions. … There are interesting similarities with Schoenberg's Verklärte Nacht … which Rebikov could not have known, as, although it had been composed in 1899, it was premiered in 1902 and published only in 1905.”

Trois Idylles: “For the cover [to the sheet music] Jurgenson commissioned an illustration of fantastical creatures: a mermaid, a frog prince, Pan, a witch, and others. The contents are hardly less odd. Bar lines and time signatures are absent from all three pieces. The solemn Hymn to the Sun … features parallel motion and intervals of a fourth and makes extensive use of note clusters, the majority of which include every white note in the span of an octave, to be played ‘with the edge of the palm.' The American Henry Cowell and the Russian-American Leo Ornstein, later credited as pioneers in this field, had yet to begin their work.”

Scènes bucoliques: “Here there is an attempt to evoke the spirit … of ancient Greece: old modes are used in the first four [pieces]; … the mercurial fifth, Round of the Elves, is built largely by stacking up minor thirds and eventually evaporates into thin air.”

Parmi eux [“Among Them”]: “portrays giant alien creatures that live in a parallel, whole-tone, world. … The first [piece], entitled The Males Dance, is heavy-footed and clumsy. Dance with a Bell features syncopated gong-like bass notes, after which a hypnotic Berceuse sends the baby off to sleep. Dance of the Quadrupeds, perhaps the aliens' proportionately huge, lumbering equivalent to our pet dog, brings to mind the more sluggish bear in Pétrouchka.”

There's a lot more in the notes (and music) than this, of course, but I hope this gives you a taste of what you'll experience in listening. As for the performances, Goldstone is a pianist of formidable technique and astonishing coordination. Not only are both hands always in perfect synch, but (again) like Lewenthal, he makes the difficult sound easy without underplaying the drama in so many of these short works.

Discovering missing links in classical music is always fun as well as instructive. Rebikov is one more missing link, as once were Gossec, Spontini, and Alkan. I cannot recommend this disc highly enough. It should be in the library of any serious student of modern music, and the best part is that these pieces are as enjoyable as they are visionary.
Lynn René Bayley

AUDIOPHILE AUDITION:
Amazingly, most of the music on this CD of delightful and stylistically varied piano miniatures has never been recorded before. Vladimir Rebikov (1866-1920), is a Russian composer who was one of the first to use the whole tone scale, as well as an innovator in using advanced harmony (seventh and ninth chords and open fourths and fifths), polytonality, and unresolved cadences. Stravinsky was aware of some of these innovations and used them in many of his works. But despite his experimentations, Rebikov never strayed from tonality.

The selections here vary from twenty-five seconds to nineteen minutes. The first two, The Devils Amuse Themselves and The Giants Dance “bear intriguing similarities to later iconic works by acknowledged composers,” notes pianist Anthony Goldstone. He's referring to Stravinsky's Rite of Spring in the first instance and Messiaen's Quartet for the End of Time in the latter. Autumn Leaves is pregnant with Russian melancholy, probably influenced by Tchaikovsky. A Festival is animated and energetic, filled with ostinato figures. The longest work on this disc, Slavery and Liberty (1901) is one of three ‘tone poems' that explored the meaning of art in an unstructured, stream of consciousness style. It's passionate, filled with emotional extremes, and uses repetition creatively.  Rebikov's popular waltz from his music-psychological drama The Christmas Tree was played as an encore by many pianists. In Three Idylls , the composer uses white notes and note clusters long before Henry Cowell and Leo Ornstein. Pictures for Children was composed for his students to use for practice, mirroring Schumann's Kindersczenen.

Adventurous British pianist Anthony Goldstone has done us a favor by discovering these engrossing miniatures and performing them with verve and understanding.
Robert Moon

CLASSICS ONLINE:
Vladimir Rebikov, often called 'the inventor of the whole-tone scale', is now almost completely forgotten, save his Silhouettes (a set of interesting children's pieces), and his Valse op.21, a popular encore piece.  Due to most of his pieces being miniatures, with definite musical phrases and simple forms (far from Satie), not many people paid attention to him.  To the disengaged, Rebikov seems like one of the many salon composers, with nothing of note.

This album does very well to dispel this notion.  Rebikov was an innovator with modest ability; he was the one who invented palm clusters (before Cowell), and wrote a piece completely in whole-tone scale (way before Debussy).  All of these landmark pieces, including a suite completely in white keys (Chansons Blanches), are included in this album, played with musicality by Goldstone. 

Other than being an innovator, he was a master of the simple forms he wielded with ease.  Consider the interesting ideas and endings of Promenade of the Gnomes, The Music Lesson, and Rondes des Elfes and you might see why.  While they may not have the substance of great masterworks, they are enjoyable to listen to and are very accessible, as they have  very clear melodic lines and 2-2-4 music phrases.

Even in his Tchaikovsky-like pieces in the suite Feuilles d'Automne, Rebikov used a few musical devices (such as obsessive repetition) that made them his own, rivaling even some of The Seasons in terms of melody and form.  For example, the comforting ending of the fourth movement, Con dolore, in contrast with its sad beginnings, exhibits a very rare poignancy that only Rebikov can provide.

In short, this is a rather valuable premiere of Rebikov's music.  The other one which I have heard, a little known album by Sheludyakov, is too ponderous and vastly inferior to this album, where the tempos are suitable.  If you want to explore more unknown composers who are simple yet enjoyable to listen to, this is highly recommended. “JY89484”

MUSICA (Italy) (joint review of vols 1-5):
This is a nice collection of CDs of the Russian piano repertoire. The next two are soon to be released [and are now available on divine art dda25095 and 25096] , but the fact that they will include Rachmaninov's and Prokofiev's pieces makes them less interesting, at least for their rarity. While, instead, recordings completely devoted to works by Arensky, Lyapunov, Glière and Rebikov are not released every day. On this our acknowledgements go to the British company [Divine Art], new on the Italian market.. The interpreter of the four single-composer CDs and also the author of the excellent informative notes included is Anthony Goldstone; while the first CD of the collection, which features several composers, is interpreted by Murray McLachlan: Kabalevsky's and Shostakovich's sonatas are not new to the record industry, but the pieces by Myaskovsky, Stevenson and Shchedrin – though not at their first recording here – can be considered real rarities.

The four composers of the monographic CDs represent, in the Russian music scene, as many different positions, equidistant from both Romanticism and Impressionism, for sure closer to Tchaikovsky than to Mussorgsky and the Group of Five; and in the case of Rebikov and Glière, who died in 1920 and 1956 – the modernistic poetics from the 20th century.

Having lived a short and profligate life, Anton Arensky left less rich a production than he could have. Still, he wrote a hundred pieces for piano, inspired by the romanticism of Chopin and Tchaikovsky, which informed his work to the utmost. He also taught Rachmaninov and Scriabin. These days Arensky is mainly renowned for the lovely waltz from the first Suite for two pianos, but his Studies and Preludes are valuable too; and mainly the six Essais sur des rythmes oubliées , Op.28, with its unusual metres.

Sergei Lyapunov (who lived a longer and more sober life than Arensky but one which was no more productive) was also a great romantic, in the line of Chopin, Liszt and Anton Rubinstein, but in his works the popular Russian tradition is more present, because he was a close friend and pupil of Balakirev, father of the “Five”, who dedicated to Lyapunov the Sonata for piano he finally completed in 1905. In answer to this Lyapunov composed the Sonata Goldstone plays here. If Arensky is renowned for his lovely waltz, works by Lyapunov are performed too every now and then, mainly during the conservatoire exams: especially some of the twelve Transcendental Studies that complete the tonal cycle Liszt started with his works of this name. The CD includes the sonata and some other works, the well-known Fêtes de Noël , Op.41, among them.

Vladimir Rebikov, the third of these composers to be born in the 1860s, died in 1920; though far less renowned than the two abovementioned, he produced a much more innovative musical language: Stravinsky himself mentions him in this sense. His innovations anticipate certain harmonic aspects of the 20th century (whole-tone system, unresolved harmonies, pieces without bars and metre, tone clusters). At the beginning of the CD Goldstone performs two short pieces where Rebikov anticipates two moments that are reminiscent of both Stravinsky ( Le sacre du printemps ) and Messiaen ( Quatuor pour la fin du temps ). Apart from this peculiarity, Rebikov's piano production, also because of his natural bent for teaching, is made up of short and very short pieces (on the CD sixteen out of forty-three last less than one minute). However, there is also a major work, a ‘tableau musical-psycologique' entitled Esclavage et liberté (Op.22). Other oddities: a cycle of seven pieces that lasts three minutes and a half ( Une fête , Op.38) and one out of four pieces written without accidentals, on white keys only ( Chansons blanches , Op.48).

While Rebikov and Lyapunov died shortly after the establishment of the Soviet regime, Reinhold Glière lived all through the period of Stalinism, outliving the dictator himself by three years. As a composer he remained a traditionalist Romantic, and he didn't reject the opportunity to celebrate a few feasts of the new regime with his music. Also Glière wrote short pieces for piano, mainly in Chopin's tradition but as well in that Russian piano music style of the day, led by the influence of Scriabin. A wonderful pianist, Arensky's and Taneyev's pupil, he reached his creative peak in the 25 Preludes Op.30 ( twenty-five as he adds to the series – which follows Bach's, not Chopin's harmonic order – one last Prelude in C major, just as Alkan did): an impressive, extremely varied and interesting series. The spirit of Chopin, inherited through his Polish mother, marks Glière's short Mazurka (Op.29), and the eloquent simplicity of the Esquisses Op.47 betrays educational, but mostly appropriate, intentions. As for his discography, Anthony Goldstone is an interpreter we can't overlook. The repertoire he presents is not just special and precious, but also put forward with remarkable cultural intelligence: each one of his CDs can be said to develop a theme. This knowledge of the various repertoires also enables him to move with extreme versatility from genre to genre, from composer to composer, from character to character: from the sentimentalism, a little frivolous, of some of Arensky's pieces, to the irony of work by Rebikov; from Lyapunov's Russian-style harmonies to the cyclical integrity of Glière's Preludes , everything performed through the vaguely archaic sound of a Grotrian piano, Goldstone convinces and charms us.
Riccardo Risaliti

CLASSICALNET (joint review with dda25083 and 25084):
These three new discs from Divine Art are dedicated to the Russian piano school and make for hugely interesting listening. The three composers are Vladimir Rebikov, Sergey Lyapunov and Reinhold Gliere, the latter two perhaps more familiar than the first one but a satisfying discovery nonetheless.

Rebikov was an excellent teacher and performer with his output including various chamber and orchestral works as well as several stage works. However his greatest legacy remains his varied and assorted collection of piano pieces which finds a good selection here. Apparently his later work includes some rather dissonant pieces which caused him to fall out of favour but the pieces recorded here remind one of such luminaries of his time such as Vaughan Williams, Scriabin, Rachmaninoff and Mompou.

Gliere who was of Belgian descent was also a dab hand on the piano as the 25 Preludes demonstrate with fantastic amounts of colour and quite amazing virtuosic demands. The same goes for the Mazurkas and also the Esquisses which have that tinge of oriental colour which we find in his orchestral works with the ballet "Red Poppy" and the massive 3 rd Symphony, "Ilya Murometz" coming to mind.

Finally there's the disc dedicated to Sergey Lyapunov who is also a master of the miniature but who composed a Piano Sonata which is unjustifiably rather neglected nowadays. I greatly enjoyed his Variations on a Georgian Theme as well as the moving "Fêtes de Noël", a lovingly created miniature for the Christmas period.

After listening to these performances for the best part of four hours, I have to say that I was bowled over by Anthony Goldstone's consummate artistry and sheer virtuosity in these multi faceted pieces. Like the Shostakovich volume, these three discs are a must acquisition for those who know and love things Russian. Fastidiously detailed notes and fine recordings complement what must be one of the highlights of piano recordings this year.
Gerald Fenech

MUSICWEB:
Vladimir Rebikov, the self-styled inventor of whole-tone music, was born in Siberia in 1866 and studied composition with Nikolai Klenovsky, a Tchaikovsky pupil. He was an experimenter and wrote ‘musico-psycholographic dramas' having increasingly turned to novel forms and moved in harmonically advanced directions. His ideas were not always well received and he, apparently, became embittered at the success of Scriabin – a name that springs to mind when listening to Rebikov's music – and even Debussy, both of whom, he believed, had stolen his ideas. Some contemporary writers did, to some degree, agree that he had anticipated their seismic shifts in harmonic thinking, though it remains moot whether they did. He certainly met Debussy as well as Grieg and Janácek. And Stravinsky certainly did know about Rebikov and admitted as much, and his early influence.
 
Given his still-ambiguous place in the history of whole-tone adventurism it's interesting to note that, as far as I'm aware, the first pieces of his to be recorded were songs. Not that he lacked for modernist experimentation in vocal music, either, but the songs sung by Zoia Rosovsky for Vocalion were not especially alarming for contemporary taste in the early 1920s. They can be found in a box set of discs devoted to the obbligato player, the great violist Lionel Tertis.
 
The piano music recorded in this Divine Art disc is part of the company's ‘Russian Piano Music' marque, itself an adventuresome jaunt amongst the highways and byways of the muse. It's clear that Rebikov managed often to fuse traditional and experimental harmonies convincingly, as he does in Feuilles d'automne where Tchaikovsky-like moments - in the Pregando – vie with the far more advanced Scriabin-evoking Con tristezza movement. The ethos manages also to marry, seemingly paradoxically, remoteness and warmth.
 
He was also an adherent of selective precision. Une fête for instance has seven movements and lasts in total three and a half minutes. Nothing is wasted. There are Stravinskian anticipations in the rhythmic charge of the music, and this little cycle shows his vitality and striking sense of rhythm. Chansons blanche uses the white keys only and aspires to a reserved plangency – which is achieved with some success. The longest piece is the grandly named Esclavage et liberté of 1901, subtitled Tableau musical-psychologique in accepted French terminology. This is a striking piece, but mainly for its Lisztian melos, a psycho-drama of pregnant anticipation that shares a similar sense of drama and contrast as Liszt's B minor Sonata. It gradually lightens and brightens its tone into extravagant chordal dynamism. It's apparent by now that Rebikov looked back as well as forward. As well as anticipating the rhythmic advances of Stravinsky and the glowering expressionism of Scriabin he also stands revealed as an inheritor of mid-nineteenth century tone poetry as well, a synthesiser of ambition unvexed by the problems he thus faced.
 
These also included the use of clusters, where he certainly was in the vanguard, and which he employs in the 1913 Trois idylls, as well as the lightly burnished orientalism of the second of the two Episodes from Yolka . He sought Arcadian-Greek inspiration in the brief Scènes bucoliques and looked back to Schumann's inspiration for the charmingly droll Tableaux pour enfants. His putative influence on French impressionism can perhaps best be gauged by the c.1906 settings in Parmi eux – note Elles dansent in particular. And it's fascinating to consider his influence on the Czech composer Novák, whom Rebikov knew and to whom the third of these pieces is dedicated, and on Novák's subsequent compositional direction, not least as a composer for the keyboard.
 
Anthony Goldstone is wholeheartedly to be commended on his playing. He reaches into the heart of the Rebikovian dilemma and produces performances of intensity and suggestive tonality. Maybe the Valse from Yolka could be more capricious – Shura Cherkassky once recorded this and his playing was lither and more treble glinting [Ivory Classics 72003] – but elsewhere he produces performances both sensitive and, in the opening track , Les démons s'amusant, puckish.
 
And with detailed notes and excellent recorded sound, this stakes a permanent claim on the listener. 
Jonathan Woolf

MIDWEST RECORD:
Just like you never heard of Salieri until Mozart [went] mainstream, again, there are a raft of Russian composers that probably never scored a blip on your radar.  Musical archeologists like Goldstone don't let that stand in their way as he raises another worthy composer from the dust bin of time and gives him his due.  You can play a lot of musical chicken/egg games here as some of his works predated masters you know yet seem eerily similar.  A great bit of hide and seek for classical enthusiasts that want to dig deeper without hav[ing] to go on a scavenger hunt to do so.
Chris Spector

CLASSICAL POINTERS:
Apart from the horrid overprintng on the covers, this Russian Piano Music Series has much to commend it for musical explorers.

Innovative in his time and an early proponent of the whole-tone scale, the all but forgotten music of Vladimir Rebikov (1866-1920) foreshadowed composers like Debussy, Scriabin, Stravinsky, Copland and Villa-Lobos. His tiny experimental pieces tackle a variety of problems; the Chansons blanches, on white keys only, anticipate Constant Lambert's 30 years on.

This survey has 42 little pieces in 50 minutes, outdoing in their brevity Webern's to come, plus one of Rebikov's few extended Lisztian Tableaux musical-psychologiques, a continuous stream-of-consciousness 20 minutes single movement.

Anthony Goldstone's comprehensive notes draw you into this unique composer's world, and he plays all the music with a winning flair, recorded close by his home in the village church at Alkborough, Lincolnshire.

Warmly recommended, and lots of worthwhile pieces to consider for piano teachers (who just might know The Christmas Tree ) [Scores available free on line]
Peter Grahame Woolf

NEW CLASSICS:
Described by The New York Times as ‘a man whose nature was designed with pianos in mind', Liverpool-born Anthony Goldstone is one of Britain's most respected pianists. A sixth-generation pupil of Beethoven through his great teacher Maria Curcio, Goldstone was born in Liverpool and studied with Derrick Wyndham at the Royal Manchester College of Music and with Curcio in London. His career has taken him to six continents and the Last Night of the Proms (where he was much praised by Benjamin Britten) as well as many broadcasts and nearly seventy CDs. He is also one half of the brilliant piano duo Goldstone and Clemmow with his wife Caroline.

The second volume of his Russian Piano Music Series features works by Vladimir Rebikov, who was born in Siberia in 1866 and died in 1920. In addition to many piano works Rebikov wrote numerous orchestral, vocal and stage pieces, including ‘musico-psycholographic dramas' in some of which he experimented by combining spoken and sung text to a musical accompaniment. He wrote in a bewildering array of styles and was admired by other composers, including Janácek, Debussy and Grieg, but despite his considerable achievements - he has been called ‘the father of Russian modernism' - Rebikov has been driven to the margins of musical history. This is borne out by the fact that, as far as can be determined, out of this recital programme only a piece of two minutes' duration has previously been recorded. Anthony Goldstone's formidable playing is technically superb and articulate, revealing all the passion and colour in this little heard music.
John Pitt

PIANIST (joint review of 25081, 25083, 25084, 25085):
More Russian repertoire comes from the pianist Anthony Goldstone who has probably the widest palette of all – and surely the brightest of all waistcoats. Goldstone is known for his extensive series of four-handed recordings with Caroline Clemmow and his solo recordings are all of immense interest. Readers may remember my job over his recent release of music inspired by dances. Here Goldstone embarks on a (long, I hope) series of Russian piano music. Composers who lived now brought out into the daylight: Arensky, with his tuneful Preludes: Lyapunov, a minor Liszt follower: Glière, more known for his large-scale orchestral music: and the least-known Rebikov, who was, however, immortalised by his Christmas Tree , once a stalwart of piano score anthologies. All of Goldstone's discs are highly satisfying, played with power and conviction and if there are not true masterpieces among the many smaller works, they are far more rewarding to listen to than many of the minor British composers living in the shadow of Elgar and Vaughan Williams.
Marius Dawn Pianist Recommended Recording

OZARTS REVIEW:
This is a most welcome addition to the discography of Russian music for the piano.

Most of the pieces here are short, ranging from durations as brief as 23 seconds to  two or three minutes. There's one larger scale offering: Esclavage et liberte which runs for just under twenty minutes. As a schoolboy growing up many years ago in Cape Town and an enthusiastic competitor in local eisteddfodau, I often played set pieces by Ladoukhin, Maykapar, Karganov, Goedicke, Rebikov – and numbers of so-called Fairy Tales by Medtner. Nearly all of these, as I recall, were published by Chester . Their level of difficulty approximated some of the trickier pieces in Schumann's Album for the Young. They were handy to play at piano teachers' end-of-term concerts and at school prize giving ceremonies.

Very few of these miniatures are available on CD which is a shame as these morceaux deserve an occasional airing – and this recording of music of Rebikov is a welcome addition to the recorded repertoire, not least because, according to the liner notes, of the 43 tracks, one – and one only – has previously been recorded. The soloist in this miniature was Shura Cherkassky who would offer it as an encore from time to time: the charming, lilting little Valse from The Christmas Tree suite.

Rebikov, born in Siberia in 1866, died in warmer climes (Yalta in the Crimea)  in  1920, leaving a great deal of music, much of it now being recorded by enterprising and adventurous pianists such as Anthony Goldstone.Rebikov wrote in a bewildering variety of styles; many are on offer here. Listen to The Devils Amuse Themselves and The Giant Dance. Both call for emphatic, foot-stamping heaviness. Goldstone presents these noisy little pieces with gusto. Bittersweet melancholy informs almost every moment of the six brief utterances that are collectively called Autumn Leaves. This is hardly great music but certainly worth an occasional airing.

A liner note suggests that the very short items that together make up A Festival anticipate the ultra-brief pieces of Webern. As well, the opening Vivo eerily calls   Stravinsky's Petrouchka to mind in its rhythmic treatment – and there's a gritty gaiety to the following miniature which Goldstone despatches with nimble, accurate fingers. Of the suite – Pictures for Children – it is The Music Lesson, in particular, that delights with its deliberate pedal blurring depicting a piano pupil very much under par And The Promenade of the Gnomes makes a graceful obeisance to Mussorgsky's Pictures at an Exhibition.
Neville Cohn